As Australia approaches its federal election, Opposition Leader Peter Dutton and the Coalition have proposed a policy allowing eligible first-time home buyers to access up to $50,000 of their superannuation savings for a home deposit.
This initiative mirrors New Zealand’s KiwiSaver HomeStart scheme, which since 2010 has permitted first-home buyers to withdraw nearly all their retirement savings, retaining only $1,000 in their accounts.
However, New Zealand’s experience serves as a cautionary tale, revealing unintended consequences such as escalating house prices and declining home ownership rates.
In the 15 years following the introduction of KiwiSaver housing withdrawals, New Zealand witnessed a 134% surge in house prices, outpacing the previous two decades and exceeding Australia’s housing price growth by 1.5 times during the same period.
This rapid appreciation has been partly attributed to increased demand fueled by the accessibility of retirement funds for home purchases.
Consequently, first-home buyers have been compelled to take on substantial mortgage debts to compete in the inflated market.
The proportion of first-home buyers with loan-to-value ratios (LVR) exceeding 80% tripled, rising from 25% to 75%. This trend indicates a significant escalation in financial risk among new homeowners.
A recent analysis by the Australian Super Members Council (SMC) warns that the super-for-housing scheme serves as a cautionary lesson for Australia.
“The overwhelming majority of leading economists and policymakers agree that demand-side measures, such as allowing superannuation withdrawals for home purchases, are poorly targeted and will not reverse the long-term decline in homeownership among younger Australians,” the SMC report states.
According to modeling conducted by the SMC last year, implementing this policy could drive Australian house prices up by an average of $75,000 (9%) across the five major capital cities.
In 2022, then-Prime Minister Scott Morrison proposed a similar super-for-housing scheme during the election campaign.
After the Coalition lost power, Labor introduced a more restrained version, allowing individuals to withdraw up to $15,000 per financial year from their voluntary super contributions, with a maximum limit of $50,000 over multiple years.
Now, Peter Dutton and the opposition are pledging a more expansive policy, permitting first-home buyers to access 40% of their superannuation—up to $50,000—for a property purchase. The scheme would also extend eligibility to separated women.
The debate over using superannuation for housing continues, with concerns about its long-term impact.
In Australia, the average super balance for men aged 30-34 is around $83,000, while women in the same age group hold about $60,000.
However, the median balance is over $10,000 lower than these averages, highlighting financial disparities.
New Zealand’s experience provides a cautionary tale. Since introducing a super-for-housing policy 15 years ago, homeownership among Kiwis in their 30s has dropped by 7%.
Meanwhile, house prices have skyrocketed by 134%, significantly outpacing Australia’s 86% increase over the same period.
While most New Zealanders who accessed their super for housing are still working, the long-term effects on retirement savings remain unknown.
However, the clear link between the policy and rising house prices suggests that allowing super withdrawals for home purchases may worsen affordability issues rather than improve them.


