A decision by popular Australian science magazine Cosmos to publish articles generated by artificial intelligence (AI) has drawn criticism from its own contributors and former editors, including two co-founders.
The CSIRO, which publishes Cosmos, says it backs the “experimental project”, which is designed to investigate the “opportunities and risks of using AI”, and scheduled to run until February 2025.
But critics say the AI service undermines journalism and was built without proper consent.
The project was the result of a 2023 grant from the Meta Australian News Fund, administered by the Walkley Foundation which supports excellence in journalism. The controversy is an example of growing anxieties around the role of AI in journalism as publishers experiment with new productivity tools. Hundreds of journalists employed by Nine Entertainment went on strike last week, partly over AI protections.
Cosmos ran into financial difficulties and lost half its staff earlier this year, having won dozens of journalism and industry awards over 20 years of publishing. National science agency CSIRO took over the publication in June.
The grant supporting AI-generated explainers pre-dates that takeover.
During two weeks last month, Cosmos published six AI-generated explainer articles on its website on topics ranging from black holes to carbon sinks.Cosmos contributors reacted to the move with disbelief, saying their work had been used to develop an AI service that generated articles and, in their opinion, undermined their role as journalists.
Many were angry they had not been consulted and said their calls to the publisher had gone unanswered.
“I’ve contacted CSIRO and the Cosmos editors twice in the last week and had no response,” Bianca Nogrady, a freelance science journalist and Cosmos contributor, said.Editorial staff at Cosmos were also not told about the proposed custom AI service, two former editors said.
According to Ian Connellan and Gail MacCallum, Cosmos’s former publisher, the Royal Institution of Australia (RiAus), did not tell them it was applying for funding for a custom AI service in late 2023, even though they were in charge of Cosmos’s editorial decisions.
“We had no knowledge of the proposal to employ AI as a background writer creator,” Mr Connellan, who was the RiAus editor-in-chief until February, said.
“As editor-in-chief, I would have said this is a bad idea.”
Ms MacCallum, Cosmos’s managing editor at the time, said there were questions to answer about the ethics of using AI in such a way.
“I’m a huge proponent of exploring AI, but having it create articles of fact is a little past my comfort zone.”


